dog waits while owner picks up poop

Must-Have Dog Poop Bags: Gotta Scoop Up the Evidence!



Lara Jill , 31st March 2024

If you buy something using the retail links in our articles, sometimes we earn a small affiliate commission. This does not impact the products we recommend.

Part of being a good pet owner is using dog poop bags to clean up after our canine companions. Unfortunately, some sidewalks, dog parks, and hiking trails are still peppered with stealthy brown landmines.

Don’t be that person and always have a stash of dog poop bags ready, whether you’re going out for a walk or go bikejoring through the woods. Regardless of whether or not it is required by municipal law, picking up after our dogs is the right thing to do.

For this post, I’m going to share Sporty Dog’s top picks for the best dog poop bags that are guaranteed to simplify your poop-scooping chores.

Read on and discover which poop bags made the cut!

What Makes a Good Dog Poop Bag?

The key qualities of a good poop bag are excellent leak-proof and tear-proof capabilities, so you won’t get caught in a sticky (or should I say, stinky) situation!

Let’s be real; no matter how much we love our pets, we don’t want their icky brown surprise! Plus, you should be able to tie the bag securely so that you can dispose of it properly and prevent unnecessary messes inside the bin.

Moreover, a good poop bag should be a cinch to separate from the roll and open. Some dog poop bags come with tear perforations and handles, making the process quick and easy.

Beyond that, it’s all about personal preference. Do you want unscented dog poop bags or those smelling like a spring garden?

Top 5 Best Dog Poop Bags

We highly recommend these five because not only are they reliable and convenient, but they are also among the most eco-friendly options to boot. Mother Earth needs you to pick up your dog’s poopsicles using any of these bags!

1. Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags (270 count)

Best Dog Poop Bags

Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags are sturdy and thick. Rest assured, you can transport doggy doo-doo to the nearest bin without the risk of leakage. The bags are also opaque, so you can’t see the contents inside.

Each bag measures 9 x 13 inches, making it suitable for any size of doggie dump. Whether you have a Shih Tzu or a Lab, the bag should have enough space to handle Sniffer’s stinky brown surprise.

These dog poop bags are also designed to fit most dispensers, but I recommend the Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Dispenser for its double-walled design and click-and-lock closure.

What I love most about these dog poop bags is that they are made of 65% post-consumer recycled plastic. Know that Earth Rated is a certified B corporation and their mission? Sending donations to animal rescues!

  • Pros

    • Spacious and long enough for easy tying
    • Eco-friendly, helping save the planet one poop bag at a time
    • Should fit most poop bag dispensers
    • Available in refill sizes of 120, 270, and 600
    • Comes in lavender and unscented versions

  • Cons

    • People with sensitivities might find the lavender scent overwhelming


Nikhil  |  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Picking up after my pup just got a whole lot easier with Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags! These bags are lifesavers. They’re super strong and leak-proof, so I never have to worry about accidents. Plus, they’re a good size to handle any mess, big or small. The lavender scent is a nice bonus too, helping to mask any unpleasant odors. And the fact that they’re made from recycled materials makes me feel good about using them. These are definitely the best poop bags I’ve ever tried—highly recommend for any dog owner!”

Abdul  |  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“Discovering scented poop bags has transformed my pet care routine! The delightful fragrance not only masks odors but also adds a pleasant touch to the cleanup process. I highly recommend them to fellow pet owners for their durability and ease of use. These bags have made managing pet waste a much more enjoyable experience, and I wanted to share this fantastic find with all of you!”

2. Peanut’s Poop Bags by The Original Poop Bags (120 count)

Best Dog Poop Bags Runner Up

Another product designed with the environment in mind is the Peanut’s Poop Bags by The Original Poop Bags.

These bags have a standout feature of being USDA Certified Biobased. Translation? They comprise of at least 38% plant-based materials. By choosing these dog poop bags, you are helping reduce the environmental impact of plastic waste.

Not only are Peanut’s Poop Bags eco-friendly, but they also boast impressive durability. You won’t need to worry about double-bagging or any other issues that might arise with flimsy bags.

These dog poop bags come in rolls that fit easily into your pocket. But if you want to take it up a notch, get the Peanut’s Poop Bag Dispenser because it looks like a fire hydrant. And let’s not forget about the cute Snoopy prints that add a touch of fun.

  • Pros

    • USDA Certified Biobased product
    • Sturdy and holds waste from dogs of all sizes
    • Should work for most poop bag dispensers
    • Available in refill sizes of 60, 120, and 360
    • Comes in fun patterns and can be used in many ways other than holding poop
    • Has a subtle orange scent

  • Cons

    • You might want to opt for the jumbo size if you have a large breed or multiple dogs


Janko  |  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“The Original Poop Bags Peanuts are a game-changer! I love that they’re USDA Biobased and environmentally friendly. Not only do they make cleanup easy, but I also feel good knowing I’m using a product that helps reduce waste. Highly recommended for eco-conscious pet owners!”

Ishtiak  |  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“The Original Poop Bags Peanuts USDA Biobased Dog Poop Bags from Chewy are a revelation in responsible pet care! Combining strength and eco-friendliness, these bags make cleanup a breeze while contributing to a healthier planet. Embracing these USDA Biobased bags ensures a positive impact on both your pet’s well-being and our environment.”

3. Pogi’s Earth-Friendly Poop Bags (300 count)

Best Dog Poop Bags with Handles

Do you find it annoying to knot a standard poop bag? Sometimes, tying a regular bag can be tricky, especially when our dogs drop huge bowel (and slightly runny) bombshells.

Good news! You can say goodbye to hassle closures with the Pogi’s Earth-Friendly Poop Bags. The sturdy handles make it straightforward to tie the bag shut.

Each bag measures 14.5 x 7 inches, so it’s even big enough if you have to simultaneously clean up after two dogs.

However, there are a few trade-offs to consider. These bags come folded in a cardboard box, so you’ll have to bring one or two bags at a time.

  • Pros

    • Easiest poop bags to close
    • Big and sturdy enough to use for multiple pets, litter box cleanup, etc.
    • Made of recyclable materials
    • Available in refill sizes of 900

  • Cons

    • Not opaque
    • The powder-fresh scent doesn’t really mask foul odors


Schlep  | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“These bags make a nasty job a little bit easier. Roomy enough for the big loads. The handles tie to make it a more secure load and it is easier to carry. It comes with a cute little sticker—a prize, if you will, like cracker jacks.”

Cyndee   ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“These are strong and large enough to hold a lot if you clean up after multiple dogs. They are also handy for disposing of ‘presents’ brought in by cats.”

4. Arm & Hammer Fresh Scent Waste Bags (180 count)

Best Dog Poop Bags for Neutralizing Odors

Not everyone is a fan of scented dog poop bags. The combination of fragrance and stinky stool may cause others to lose their cool—an assault on their delicate senses!

You can choose unscented versions or better yet, get the Arm & Hammer Fresh Scent Waste Bags. These dog poop bags are most effective at suppressing odors, as they have activated baking soda. While it still has an added fragrance, it isn’t overpowering.

Each plastic bag measures 9 x 14 inches. The bags were purposely designed to be slightly see-through so that you won’t confuse the contents for something else, especially if you have alternative uses in mind.

Most importantly, these bags are robust! You won’t have to worry about it tearing up while picking up crap cakes on rough surfaces like concrete.

  • Pros

    • Effectively neutralizes foul odors with baking soda
    • Added fragrance isn’t overwhelming
    • Holds a big load and still leaves enough space to tie the edges
    • Should fit standard poop bag dispensers
    • Available in refill sizes of 90 and 180

  • Cons

    • So sturdy that sometimes it’s difficult to separate a bag from the roll


Carolyn  |  ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“I was looking for a bag that would hold a good amount of poop and still be able to twist and loop it into a knot. These are it; about 2 inches wider than most standard bags and half an inch taller. That makes a huge difference. I don’t like stopping in the cold and struggling to get the bag knotted.”

Teresa  |   ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“I have tried other brands and I always end up going back to these waste bags. I have never had any of the bags unperforated, leaving holes, which has occurred with other brands. And I love the baking soda smell. Keeps my cats’ poop smell under control. I do not even bother with other brands anymore.” 

5. Pet N Pet Dog Poop Bag Rolls (1080 count)

For pet owners who want to save time, money—and the planet—the PET N PET Dog Poop Bag Rolls might be the best choice for you. With a whopping 1080 bags in one box, you are set for at least a year of poop scooping.

These are USDA Certified Biobased products, making them a guilt-free option for environmentally conscious dog lovers. With a flat bottom, tear perforation, and an “Open” arrow, each 9 x 13-inch bag is easy to use and separate from the roll.

  • Pros

    • Super value pack
    • USDA Certified Biobased product
    • Spacious and should leave enough space to tie the edges
    • Should fit standard poop bag dispensers
    • With tear perforation and an "Open" arrow for quick detachment
    • Available in unscented and lavender versions

  • Cons

    • Some pet owners think that the bags feel thinner than anticipated


Anna  |   ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Greatest Value for Your Money!

“I recently discovered that Pet N Pet Dog Poop Bags are a dependable and practical way to clean up after my dog. The method is hassle-free because the bags are strong and simple to use. Because of their small size, they are ideal for use while traveling or going for walks. I like that each box has a lot of products, making it a great value for the money. All things considered, PET N PET Dog Poop Bags are a sensible option for conscientious pet owners because they offer simplicity and quality.”

Fabrizio  |   ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

“One of the standout features of PET N PET Dog Poop Bags is their unwavering commitment to the environment. Crafted from eco-friendly materials, these bags not only provide a trustworthy solution for pet waste disposal but also contribute to a healthier planet. As someone who values sustainability, I appreciate the strides PET N PET has taken in creating a product that aligns with eco-conscious principles. Also, These poop bags stand out for their remarkable strength and durability. The robust construction ensures a secure and tear-free cleanup experience, even when dealing with larger messes. Highly recommend!”

Do I Really Need Dog Poop Bags?

Some pet owners might be wondering, “Why can’t I just use the plastic bags I got from the store?”

You can’t reuse bags from grocery stores, as they aren’t suited to pick up dog waste. Not only are these containers see-through, they are simply not designed to hold liquids or prevent poop particles from permeating through plastic. It’s like trying to carry water with a colander.

Picture this. You’re on your way to the trash can when all of a sudden, the bag betrays you and Sniffer’s caca cocktails seep through and put your fingers in an unpleasant situation. How frustrating and embarrassing!

owner scoops poop while her dog lies on grass

Often these bags aren’t eco-friendly, either. Imagine using at least two plastic waste bags a day for one dog and then multiplying that number by millions of dogs worldwide. That’s a lot of plastic waste that could have been avoided with the right choice of poop bags.

Keep in mind that dog poop contains microorganisms that can cause illnesses. Unlike wild animals, dog poop is not fertilizer and it can contaminate waterways and farmlands.


We need to have poop bags on hand while we’re out and about with our canine companions. As responsible pet owners and residents of this beautiful planet, we must always do our part and keep our surroundings clean. Also, a tip: feed Sniffer the best dog food because a diet of cheap kibble requires a correspondingly higher percentage of poop scooping.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most environmentally friendly way to dispose of dog poop?
The simplest way is to collect dog waste in a bag and then dispose of it in a designated pet waste bin or a composting facility if you’re using biodegradable bags.
How do you pick up dog poop without feeling it?
A pooper scooper, or poop scoop, should make the task more easier and hygienic. This device has a bag attachment, which allows you to directly deposit dog waste into the bag for disposal.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top